If A is true, the corpse Roose saw could be the corpse of a Stannis impostor, arranged by Stannis himself (to trick the Boltons into believing that he is no longer a threat) or by Ramsay (he couldn't find Stannis' body, but still wanted to impress his dad. She lied to Davos and Mel because she wanted to mislead them and make them suffer." 4- I do not believe that she would have panicked on the first place. My Lady! How do you know that Stannis was not involved? Yet Brienne is still on the show. Please try again later{{ /verifyErrors }}, Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number, Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters, You must be over 18 years old to register. Well, there we disagree. I do not own the picture. At Comic-Con on Friday, the director of the episode came out with it. He will wright the show based on what he believes. He could have escaped. GRRM wouldn't since his list is good seeing the series. The Mannis upstair is too hairy to be him. It's not even the same armor. "A game of my horse is bigger than your horse." She pinched the bridge of her nose. Look Jon. As far as I am concerned, she has never said something like; "I don't feel like a Lady," or "Please don't call me a Lady, I don't feel like one." Gwendiline Christie was (to my knowledge) never spotted either. Fourth season: He burns a Florent for not believing the Red God and the Bank of Braavos does not come to him but he comes begging to them few gold. Ramsay has been known to fake bodies before (at least in the books)). It was his right, his birthright. He not being what she expected is not a valid point to argue if you stop and think about it. (All the people who woke up to the sound of thousands of men walking and thousands of horses neighing, and all the guards in the camp would either have intentionally not raised the alarm or have been threatened into silence immediately after they spot the deserters.) GRRM wouldn't since his list is good seeing the series. What this means for the onscreen version of Stannis is unclear. Out. Obviously, if there were both soldiers there to aid Stannis and Pod distracted her, Stannis could easily escape. And Ned not having stronger arguments against Renly is really the most valid point that piece has. What really happened, was that Mel gave Stannis a potion that enhances warging abilities. Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in, Please refresh your browser to be logged in, George RR Martin has confirmed that Stannis Baratheon is very much, Up to 30% off electricals in the Very Black Friday sale, Up to 20% off and extra perks with Booking.com Genius membership, Get $30 off orders over $200 with this Aliexpress promo code, 15% off selected items using this eBay discount code, Extra 10% off selected lines when you join Marks & Spencer Sparks, Compare broadband packages side by side to find the best deal for you, Compare cheap broadband deals from providers with fastest speed in your area, All you need to know about fibre broadband, Best Apple iPhone Deals in the UK November 2022, Compare iPhone contract deals and get the best offer this November, Compare the best mobile phone deals from the top networks and brands. You may disagree on this, but I think that in the heat of the moment, when Pod has raised the alarm, told Brienne that he has spotted Sansa and insists that they get the horses and go after her, before they lose what may be their last chance to save her, Brienne may feel so compelled to rescue Sansa, and feel sufficient difficulty in killing Stannis, that she turns away from him and hurries after Sansa. From the very first season it began, with the whole Renly/Eddard discussion. Benioff is wrong on this. Besides, Rhaegar dishonored and caused distress for House Stark and House Baratheon by abducting Lyanna, he was not a worthy protector of the realm. She also takes issue with Sansa lying. He was doing this. The way she killed the unarmed soldier was pretty messed up, but if I remember right they did awful things to the bodies that Brienne found and she might have felt it was justice that way. Well, there we disagree. He is sometimes known as "the Just" or "the Cursed" History. But it would not be possible to choose both of the alternatives I gave. ", 1- Yes, probably, but not on a degree that would save him from her, far from that. Season 3, Mlisandre goes to the brotherhood without Banner. Oh, but he was. I have very mixed feelings about Stannis. In the first season I don't think there was any sort of signs for their dislike of the character. Eric Vilas-Boas is a former editor at Esquire, where he managed the magazine's social media accounts, helped edit the website, and has written stories about comic books, martinis, and Ernest Hemingway's hamburger acumen. Probably a picture of older seasons. That should have made her cooler about Renly's death. But really anyone with royal blood could be king/queen somehow. Noble enough to stab-rape a wounded, unarmed soldier to death and getting some weird sexual satisfaction from it. The way she killed the unarmed soldier was pretty messed up, but if I remember right they did awful things to the bodies that Brienne found and she might have felt it was justice that way. "I did." Yeah, that's the best argument for him being dead. Yet they didn't. But if she did do it, why is she more bitter about it now, than before she got her revenge? If Martin says Stannis is alive beyond a doubt then that suggests the contents of the pink letter are a complete lie. Succession doesnt happen how it should a lot of the time. Especially if it's the One True King of Westeros. He may have had something going on with Melisandre for the greater good, but he would never take a second wife, or kill his wife Selyse to marry another, younger and more beautiful. We're given no in-show reason to believe she was distracted, and lying about something like this seems out of character for her. I reckon it is just one of Stannis's soldiers Jon will round up the survivors of Stannis's army for BastardBowl as for the pic with the shields the swords don't look like stannis's. Do you really believe that she do not know? So I agree there. But it would not be possible to choose both of the alternatives I gave. She did lie in that scene but only so that she and Jaime would not be attacked, so she needed to do so. No yelling could stop that sword once it goes down. Probably a picture of [view original content]. Stephen Dillane is honest about it: it's a job after all, and you need to pay the bills and get money. According to George R.R. It would explain why she still is so hostile towards Stannis' supporters. And when it comes to Eddard, as we know he didn't buy into Renly's shite. She's so mean to Melissandre and Davos because she knew that they had a hand in Renly's murder. So yeah, he ded. I acknowledged he isn't liked by some nobles, but I think it's the show's view through Renly's speech who make you think that. What We Know About 'The White Lotus' Season Two, PSA: This Is Your 'Succession' Season 4 Update, Everything We Know About 'Euphoria' Season 3, 'House of the Dragon' Rivals 'Thrones's Brutality, The 25 Best Game of Thrones Characters, Ranked, 'Game of Thrones' Cast Reacts to Jon Snow Spin-Off. But even if she did suspect Davos and Mel, it does not make sense for Brienne to be that bitter. Martin's series The Song of Ice and Fire have been wondering since the recent finale of the latest season: Is Stannis Baratheon alive or dead? Robert was a direct, trueborn descendant of Aegon Tar [view original content]. 4.3- The books are perfect. She's so mean to Melissandre and Davos because she knew that they had a hand in Renly's murder. Also this rightful king stuff is so dumb, wh moreoever takes the thrones is the rightful king, I dont know why everyone bleats on about it. Davos and Melisandre didn't even ask or accuse her of anything, she told them unprovoked. Score: 4.7/5 (30 votes) . Someofficial books of the series mentionned him dead. Yet he was the perfect actor to play Stannis, seeing how both have similarities and are bond to do their "duties". I do not own the picture. 4.1- So you think that she do not know She knows that he did not kill Renly alone, she knows he was not a sorcerer. Every product was carefully curated by an Esquire editor. That can explain the whole hate and the "love" when he was South and North, even if we may think the Northerners back him for profit. He even sentenced Davos to death. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our, Women Could Win Both Top Spots in Government, Some Say the Democratic Party Has Failed Them, Digital Ok well I already know any counter argument is just going to be brushed off because Stannis is the one true king (which is a matter of opini moreon and not fact, he's a flawed person like everyone else and I don't see how he's important enough to warrant plot armor). The books are soooooo much better. But imagine Pod running towards Brienne, shouting: My Lady! Do you really believe that she do not know? This video could not even understand how the Sansa character works, like if someone has changed only by showing strength in a single scene. It would make her more hesitant and perhaps she would feel a little guilty. How do you know that Stannis was not involved? When did she do this? I don't think Stannis was a significantly better person in that scene compared to how he was before, but my point was that Brienne finally saw that Stannis was not the monster she thought he was. Fourth season: He burns a Florent for not believing the Red God and the Bank of Braavos does not come to him but he comes begging to them few gold. I'm ok with the writers who don't like him (it's their taste after all) but in the series t morehey should have been impartial (they were still sticking close to the books at this moment); them not liking its character made his character butchered imo. Well, Benioff's interpretation is still valid. He admitted that "I did" kill Renly, not "we did". Sure, because of this compromise we missed the, son 1, if you want a better explanation read this: http://turtle-paced.tumblr.com/post/126247067372/introducing-stannis-book-1-vs-season-1 Directors rarely cut away from the action if they want to kill off a main character. I think something similar could happen to Brienne (given she is pressured by Pod to hurry after Sansa). Thats not a lie. I honestly don't think he isn't aware of it. She also takes issue with Sansa lying. Third season: Balon is still alive, yet Stannis wants to burn his nephew. Wouldn't it make sense for Brienne to panic, shift focus and hurry after Sansa if Pod shouted something like that? Season 4 was Joffery Baratheon. I don't count Brienne killing Stannis not noble, that was a vow she swore after Renly died. And I gave an explanation for her lying. Obviously, if there were both soldiers there to aid Stannis and Pod distracted her, Stannis could easily escape. All these theories you have are just as baseless And she was mean to Davos and Mel because she believes they helped Stannis murder Renly. Brienne is very dutiful, I doubt she would have abandoned her post for Sansa just to find Stannis, spare him, then lie about it for no reason later. Burning Shireen was a great sacrifice, and they would believe that their campaign is now blessed by a god. But we have to remember that those men had good reasons to desert on the first place. Stannis, his wife, and his men watched in anguish as the poor girl was burned alive. But in preview chapters for the upcoming Winds of Winter that Martin posted online way back in 2012, that rumor proved untrue. What he thinks happened is what happened. She may have suspected that Davos and Mel were involved, but as far as I am concerned, she has no reason for it. It makes one wonder why they decided to not show what happened to Stannis. . I meant that she only wanted Stannis ex-followers to felt the same way she did when Renly was Dead and there was nothing that she could do. Did they not mean to kill him? She said Renly is the rightful king because she believed that to be true, and in her eyes, eventhough she's technically a lady in that she comes from a noble house, she doesnt feel like one. We se Tormund Giantsbane and some of his allies behind him, in the lower right corner of the screen, charging into battle. Sometimes we don't always need to see the body. Steffon was the head of House Baratheon and Lord Paramount of the Stormlands. What other times she's lied, please let me in on that because I dont recall any. "Coming soooooo close to avenging Renly, but ending up having to let Stannis go. "I did." Martins answer throws one of the books most intriguing mysteries off-balance: the details of what the fandom have nicknamed the pink letter. (and see a resurrected Bric Dondarrion). Stannis is the head of House Baratheon of Dragonstone and the Lord of Dragonstone. We know this far that Brienne is fairly noble, and does not lie if she does not have to. We have to find her before the Boltons do! Davos and Melisandre didn't even ask or more accuse her of anything, she told them unprovoked. I personally think that they could make this more interesting by bringing him back. 24 Mar 2017. 2- Agreed. We have no time to lose! You have to notice that everything here is open to interpretations, that one being Benioff's. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Let's just say that if Stannis was a real person, a politician for example, he wouldn't get nearly as much love as he gets as a fictional character (just like he doesn't get much love in Westeros), because his attitude towards others is often so cold and he isn't really good at inspiring people's love and devotion. If they want a good chance at finding her, instead of losing track of her forever, they would have to take action immediately. I can't remember it. And I gave an explanation for her lying. That is a lie Brienne tells her self in order to sleep at night. Ok well I already know any counter argument is just going to be brushed off because Stannis is the one true king (which is a matter of opinion and not fact, he's a flawed person like everyone else and I don't see how he's important enough to warrant plot armor). Well, it's a long swim to Cairo, but good luck to you. Davos looks horrified, but Brienne - not for the first time - takes pleasure in the suffering of others. If she did, she should have asked Stannis about it. nothing definitive has been said yet about Jon Snow's fate, HBO New Releases 2022: What to Watch on HBO Now. Season 3 was Robb Stark. George R. R. Martin gives us hope for a fallen "Game of Thrones" star. I think Balon staying alive has more to do with how they decided to do the Ironborn storyline than anything with Stannis. And considering that Melisandre is a big fraud, there probably was no shadow baby. George R. R. Martin confirmed to a fan in 2015 that Stannis is still alive in the books. Since he has lost so many Baratheon soldiers in the show and lacks Baratheon men, it would make sense that some of the soldiers who fight right by his side comes from another house that is loyal to him. I don't count Brienne killing Stannis not noble, that was a vow she swore after Renly died. "He admitted it, you know." GRRM mentionned the dead in the series and he talked about Stannis while he didn't mention about Jon Snow. "And I'm the horse." "So it's the bastard your sleeping with." Tyrion didn't look at her. whoever takes the thrones is the rightful king HBO. Being in the same room for 3 years playing almost all your scenes in it isn't the kind of role you would want to play, or understand. He is the younger brother of Robert Baratheon and the elder brother of Renly Baratheon. Thanks to you, the fal morese King Stannis Baratheon is dead. It'd honestly be really great to see him back, but probably not so high on his pedestal of greatness. I dont know why everyone bleats on about it. Of course Renly would say Stannis is not suited to be a King, that's the whole excuse for his claim. Also, she would have finished him first and only then gone after Sansa. I said "if she had the choice between IMMEDIATELY running after a defenseless girl in danger," and she will not run after Sansa immediately if she kills Stannis first. While Ramsay marries Jons sister Sansa in the TV show, in the books he marries a Northern girl posing as Arya Stark to retain his houses hold of the North. In the series,. I dont know if they especially dislike the character however I'm pretty sure they dont buy into all this Mannis junk, they invested plenty into the character. From the very first season it began, with the whole Renly/Eddard discussion. Sure, I just wanted to complete. he was exactly the same (sorry to break it up for you). But it can't. Not with out your help. Look Ser Davos. And when it comes to Eddard, as we know he didn't buy into Renly's shite. Sure, because of this compromise we missed the [view original content]. No, that's just wrong. We have to go Now! Get. The show is great. Sure, because of this compromise we missed the whole "two is not three" or whatever, but I wouldn't say the motivation behind this decision had anything to do with Stannis. Main characters usually get their death on screen. If A is true, the corpse Roose saw could be the corpse of a Stannis impostor, arranged by Stannis himself (to trick the Boltons into believing that he is no longer a threat) or by Ramsay (he couldn't find Stannis' body, but still wanted to impress his dad. Why would he do it if not aware of the true nature of Rattleshirt? Martin, the supposedly slain Baratheon is still alive at least in the books. They could've used CGI, I agree. But we have to remember that those men had good reasons to desert on the first place. The actor (Stephen Dillane) even said in an interview couple months ago that he was never really a big fan of GoT, and that doesn't sound like the talk of someone who still has a contract. To rally the north in rebellion against the Boltons of course. She needed 12 seconds to summon her will to swing her sword at Stannis after he said "Go on, do your duty." If Tyrion can use that logic to spare Jorah, so can Brienne. Let's just say that if Stannis was a real person, a politician for example, he wouldn't get nearly as much love as he gets as a fictional character (just like he doesn't get much love in Westeros), because his attitude towards others is often so cold and he isn't really good at inspiring people's love and devotion.