Arthur replied "Then you shall have it, ser." @the_red_viper: Again, very much an over exaggeration. Gregor Clegane is like a buff guy in real life. Ser Arthur Dayne, known as the Sword of the Morning, is a famed and legendary knight from House Dayne and a member of the Kingsguard. Dayne takes either alone, but I think the Clegane brothers together win after a tough fight. Dayne has a severe reach disadvantage. Culture His strength is "nothing human" and his thighs look like small trees. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Arthur Dayne vs Wun Wun thread???? He was extremely principled and dutiful, following to the highest of his capacities the orders of his royal masters. Family 2022 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. I'm going with Dayne. Could Ser Arthur Dayne kill The Mountain in a duel (Game of Thrones)? The most badass knight in Westeros simply twirls his swords and cuts off both their heads. Gender Peter Parker gets drafted by an NFL team. if they worked together tho, they would most likely win, but not easily. Who is the best fighter we have seen so far in the first (Spoilers All) How did Rhaegar and Arthur become friends? What I'm saying is that Gregor does have the attributes to pull out a win, thus making him a formidable opponent, And again, most of the time, maybe 8 out of 10 times Dayne can beat Gregor. He's just too fast and skilled for them, they're both too slow to contend. [2] He was the brother of Lady Ashara Dayne and Lady Allyria Dayne. For information regarding the procedure that needs to be exactly followed to register there, please click here. (It should be pointed out, though, that the brothers' teamwork probably won't be as smooth as that of the Tower of Joy team -- Gregor's fighting style, largely due to his choice of weapon, hardly seems considerate towards allies fighting in close proximity! Hailing from Dorne, he was a member of Aerys II's Kingsguard and the man to knight Jaime Lannister. I would argue that the fight would have ended long before Gregor broke his spear if Oberyn wasn't toying with him and was perfectly serious. He was the brother of Lady Ashara Dayne and Lady Allyria Dayne. The Smiling Knight was a prominent member of the outlaws called the "Kingswood Brotherhood" and was mentally imbalanced. Ser Arthur Dayne while leading the Kingsguard in suppressing the outlaws, fought him in single combat. Appearances Oberyn was toying with him like a Lego figure. Plus, even if he toyed, if he loses his weapon in a fight where you wouldn't be handed another, he would be done for. During the . Arthur was Prince Rhaegar Targaryen's closest friend. [2] Jaime Lannister, who worshiped Arthur in his youth, claims quite correctly that Arthur could easily best all of the current Kingsguard with his left hand 'while taking a piss with the right'. Books snap.berkeley.edu He was the only Dornish member along with Lewyn Martell of the Kingsguard under King Aerys II Targaryen. Siblings He fought off four opponents with no injury, two wont do too much. Dayne is very, very fast and extremely skilled taking on and nearly besting 4 highly competent opponents at once Arthur Dayne He spent his youth being taught the art of arms at Starfall, and was eventually deemed worthy of wielding Dawn, the ancestral blade of House Dayne. Gregor is not good against fast/skilled opponents. It wouldn't stagger Arthur or knock him down? Many considered him to have been the most chivalrous warrior of the Seven Kingdoms. Ser Arthur Dayne was a knight of House Dayne who bore the title of "Sword of the Morning" as he possessed the ancestral sword of House Dayne, Dawn. Biographical Information I don't think Arthur would be able to block the mountains strikes with 1 blade and attack with the other like he did during the tower of joy fight, he would need both swords at the very least, at most he would need to evade those strikes entirely. The hound killed 4 dudes in that tavern, easily killed 3 dudes trying to rape Sansa, *spoiler* killed like 3 kingsguard in about 3 seconds before cleganebowl ( https://youtu.be/vn5wloyBHnA ) this feat is almost better than daynes feat honestly, he killed 3 kingsguard like they were nothing, despite them having higher ground than him, all the soldiers he's ever killed have just as many feats as all the soldiers dayne has killed on screen, which is no feats, we've never seen dayne kill anyone with feats, period.. daynes one feat, while flashy, is not all that impressive, if he tries to pull dual swords on the mountain and hound his parrys would cripple under their attacks, one sword and his odds seem worse considering we have no showings of him using 1 sword. Who would win in a fight Jaime Lannister vs Aragorn? The only difference is that he gloated to a crowd before dodging again. Many considered him to have been the most chivalrous warrior of the Seven Kingdoms. Originally Answered: Could Arthur Dayne defeat the mountain? Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass! Arthur Dayne vs Wun Wun thread???? 52 results 1 2 On_Comicvine247 Poll Ser Arthur Dayne vs The Mountain & The Hound (64 votes) The most badass knight in Westeros simply twirls his swords and cuts off both their heads 33% Tis a. or before 260 AC, at Starfall (Presumably) Arthur had the reputation of being the noblest knight since Prince Aemon the Dragonknight, and the most famous Dornishman of his day (excepting his own sister and Prince Oberyn Martell). In Westeros this is pretty much the consensus. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Ser Arthur Dayne vs The Mountain/Jorah Mormont | FanVerse Allegiance The Smiling Knight was an outlaw and a member of the Kingswood Brotherhood. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Clegane brothers easily, dayne is overrated, what did he do that the hound hasn't really? Both Clegane brothers are better fighters than Ned. Yes he lost cause he was at oberyn's mercy and he would have died if it hasn't been for oberyn's overconfidence. @princearagorn1@deadpoolvironfist@pope052@fallschirmjager@jedixman@godzilla44@sophia89@cregan_stark@i_like_swords@The_Deathstroker@thenaughtytitan@superdrummer@zill0678@marty2187@sergeant-rl3 @lubub55@thecrazybean@the_wspanialy@thesuperor@xerolot@demohardt@educated. tough one. Now that we have seen Ser Arthur Dayne fight in yesterday's GOT episode, do you think he can take on Gregor Clegane(The Mountain). He is the brother of, Lord Dustin Dayne, Lady . Honestly i gotta give it to Dayne here maybe 6/10 times. Classification: Human, Knight, Kingsguard, Sword of the Morning, Powers and Abilities: Superhuman Physical Characteristics, Weapon Mastery and Skilled Horse Rider, Attack Potency: Wall level+ (Traded several blows against a young Eddard Stark and three other warriors at the same time[2]. He knighted Jaime Lannister for his efforts in defeating the dreaded Kingswood Brotherhood, and would personally kill one of their most notorious members, the Smiling Knight. Gregor Clegane, the Mountain that Rides, is no doubt stronger and much larger, equipped with extra thick heavy armor. Tier: 9-B, higher with Dawn Name: Arthur Dayne Origin: Game of Thrones Gender: Male Age: Unknown Classification . Then I think the most renowned swordsman in recent Westeros history would make efficient work of the mountain. But he still got utterly dismantled by Oberyn who ONLY lost for his own hubris and desire for a confession, he could have finished him off at any moment once he had him downed. He is sloppy. He just gets cut a few more times. He was the older brother of Ashara Dayne and Allyria Dayne, and the uncle of Edric Dayne. Could Arthur Dayne beat the Mountain if both faced off during - reddit TV Dayne can definitely beat the Mountain. If that was in the battlefield it would have been game over. The World of Ice & Fire (mentioned)A Game of Thrones (mentioned)A Clash of Kings (mentioned)A Storm of Swords (mentioned)A Feast for Crows (mentioned)A Dance with Dragons (mentioned), Ser Arthur Dayne, known as the Sword of the Morning, was a famed and legendary knight from House Dayne and a member of Aerys II Targaryen's Kingsguard. In order to keep the Tower of Joy scene a secret during production, Luke Roberts was announced as playing Lord "Rowland Selwyn" instead of Arthur Dayne - apparently an amalgamation of the names of Howland Reed and, In the novels, Dawn is a Greatsword similar to. In the novels, Dawn is a Greatsword similar to Ice, which Ser Arthur wields with both hands, whereas in the show, the Greatsword (which seems to be scaled down in order for the Actor to work with two swords at once) is wielded alongside a second blade in the off-hand in order to display Arthur's skill at swordsmanship. Who would win in a fight between Ser Arthur Dayne and Ser Gerold He was a Kingsguard under King Aerys II Targaryen. I'd say yes. It's said that Dawn has a strength of its own and Dayne was no weakling himself. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. If Oberyn Martell can take down the mountain using reach and speedWho obviously was a very very talented duelist. It is possible that he looked like his sister, who was dark-haired, tall and extremely beautiful with violet eyes. Game of Thrones DeathMatch! - Arthur Dayne vs. Barristan Selmy Dayne can take either of them in 1v1 battle with mid-difficulty, but in no way is he soloing both. Guys, there's no way he's taking them both at once. [1], Arthur was Prince Rhaegar Targaryen's closest friend. He beats either of them individually, but not together, assuming the Hound and Mountain work together. Gregor Clegane in the show was very slow and he threw wild telegraphed swings. Died Smiling Knight - A Wiki of Ice and Fire with hes dual swords, of hes greatsword its a rough one. Even as an adult, Eddard regarded Arthur as strong and the greatest knight who ever lived[1]), higher with Dawn, Speed: Superhuman with Subsonic Reactions (Can keep up with several opponents at the same time[2]), Striking Strength: Wall Class+ (Notched the Smilling Knight's longsword so many times that he stopped the combat to let him fetch a new one, killing him in the end[1]), higher with Dawn, Durability: Wall level+, higher with armor, Range: Standard melee range, extended melee range with swords, Standard Equipment: Dawn and a second sword, Kingsguard armor, Intelligence: Above Average (Stated to be the greatest knight who ever lived, was able to keep up with several opponents at the same time). In 283 AC, at the tower of joy Arthur paused the fight and allowed the outlaw to take a fresh sword. Oberyn knew he could strike the Mountain while the Mountain could not strike him, forcing the Mountain to go on the offensive, tiring himself out and opening himself to attacks. Title ;)only arya stark can beat wun wun. Game of Thrones Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. He was a Kingsguard under King Aerys II Targaryen. The Elder Scrolls metaphysics & philosophy, Can keep up with several opponents at the same time, Notched the Smilling Knight's longsword so many times that he stopped the combat to let him fetch a new one, killing him in the end. He is regarded by many, among them his killer, as the greatest knight who ever lived. Gregor lost to oberryn. I don't see him doing something he wouldn't do. Arthur Dayne | Goff Wiki | Fandom His nephew, the son of Arthur's unknown . Oberyn prolonged the fight on purpose because he wanted Gregor to confess his sins. Regardless, we got off-topic. Did Arthur Dayne use two swords? - mcdonald.youramys.com His nephew, the son of Arthur's unknown older brother, is Lord Edric Dayne.[3]. SerSword of the Morning Arthur very rarely faced someone who could truly match him, with the rare exceptions being the Smiling Knight and (presumably and debatably) Lord Eddard Stark. Gregor Clegane vs Arthur Dayne - General (ASoIaF) - Westeros He did spins to get away from him, like he would do in any fight. Arthur Dayne, last but not least, was the greatest knight of his generation, and the deadliest of King Aerys II Targaryen's Kingsguard (which is saying something, since it consists of Barristan the Bold, the fierce Gerold Hightower and the prodigy Jaime Lannister). Plus a large shield and greatsword will give him reach and great protection. Dayne is obviously a smart guy and a good strategist. Arthur Dayne - A Wiki of Ice and Fire Arthur Dayne | VS Battles Wiki | Fandom Arthur Dayne | A Song of Ice and Fire Wiki | Fandom He failed to kill ned stark and Howland reed (total pushovers and MUCH more honorable fighters than the mountain and hound, this alone should prove they would wreck him), and dayne managed to kill some high level fodder in a 3 or 4 v 1. We have moved to a new external forum hosted at https://vsbattles.com. He is just a bad match-up for Dayne. The Dragon Radar now also detects Infinity Stones as well One lightly armed 7 year old every day for ten years, or Kratos (God of War) vs Ra (Egyptian Mythology), Press J to jump to the feed. During the fight with the Viper alongside comments from other characters The Mountain is weak to fast and skilled fighter. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. He's obviously much much more skilled than either Gregor or the Hound. Wielding a famous greatsword Dawn, Arthur was described as being utterly unstoppable with bare steel, and nobody could stand against him on their best day. . he would beat either one of them rather easily in a 1v1. Gregor can make a claim against him, adding Sandor solidifies their victory. So that tells a lot. In a one-on-one situation Dayne should take a very clear majority over Gregor and a firm one over Sandor, but I think taking on the two Cleganes at once is largely impossible in the ASOIAF universe. Arthur Dayne, the Sword of the Morning, on the other hand is most notably remarked as the greatest knight in recent Westorosi history. If you love to imagine the planet-exploding battles of the fictional gods who will never be, taking pointless knowledge gathered from a life spent reading and gaming and swinging it like a gladiator's sword in discussions on reddit then welcome home, my friend. I really can't see how he can take Dayne. The Mountain has size power and strength to be sure, but he's more or less a pure brawler and relies on intimidation, his colossal weapon and sturdy armor. My bet is that he did all those acrobatics just to annoy Gregor. Male New posts. Dayne wins. You are indeed where you belong. Smiling Knight | Game of Thrones Wiki | Fandom The Smiling Knight did so, but remarked that it was Arthur's famous sword Dawn that he truly desired. Mountain and the hound would win. During the fight with the Viper alongside comments from other characters The Mountain is weak to fast and skilled fighter. Ser Arthur Dayne perished, and Lord Stark would return Dawn to Starfall out of honour for his opponent. He is very big and strong. Assuming they are willing to work together, they win, might as well put him against Wun Wun lol. Ser Arthur Dayne, known as the Sword of the Morning, was a famed and legendary knight from House Dayne and a member of Aerys II Targaryen's Kingsguard. Dayne could easily beat each individually, but both of them together should be too much. Armed with the ancestral greatsword Dawn, on par or better than the valyrian steel swords, the highly skilled Ser Arthur Dayne is a force to be reckoned with. In character those two will just kill each other for him. The Mountain is not the most skilled warrior with sword. @the_red_viper: That's also his personality, to be a showman. ), @cdiddyman911: Neither can take him 1 on 1 and if he had Dawn he'd slice and dice them, @kgb725: Maybe not for a majority, but there are multiple scenarios in which Gregor can beat him with raw strength. Not on the level of the Mountain but when combined with his skill he should be able to redirect the strikes around himself so he won't have to rely entirely on keeping his distance and moving fast.Edit: fight in question. Plus, he can't 'slice and dice' the armor they wear. Probably not. Arthur Dayne (A Song of Ice and Fire) - VS Battles Wiki The Mountain alone would demand the full attention from Ser, one miscalculation vs that monster and you are dead no matter how skilled you are. Dayne is very, very fast and extremely skilled taking on and nearly besting 4 highly competent opponents at once. He uses his size and his double handed sword which he uses with one hand. The skill he showed in that battle was incredible. Arthur Dayne could defeat either of the brothers on his own. Dayne wins,and based on the books Dayne should take this without much trouble. Ser Arthur Dayne vs The Mountain/Jorah Mormont Thread starter Matty; Start date Jun 2, 2016;