Robert's Rebellion was based on a lie. That being said, it may be the case that there was a Lie here; the Starks reached a conclusion that Lyanna was abducted as opposed to Eloped. Daenerys will come to terms with the issue, because all she wanted was a family anyway. Robert's rebellion was it. @RichardC: Robert B would not have been happy, but he would have no leg to stand on. arryn refused, called his banners and the rebellion began. How long do you think it took for them to travel? The rebellion was a long time coming. Others eventually knew Lyanna went willingly. As the seventh season of Game of Thrones has made clear, the alleged abduction of Lyanna Stark was actually an elopement and lawful marriage. Brandon went to King's Landing to challenge Prince Rhaegar to "Come out and die". With all the prisoners executed, still no one lifted a finger. Brandon's treasonous acts: riding up to the Red Keep and asking for Rhaegar's head for stealing Lyanna. Sci-Fi Book With Cover Of A Person Driving A Ship Saying "Look Ma, No Hands! Lyanna's alleged kidnapping was the cause of the uproar of Robert's breakdown which ultimately led to his rebellion. It was an unexpected move from Prince Rhaegar, whose silvery hair and good looks made him a heartthrob to every woman in his wake. References Now that all of our over a decade long predictions about Jon's true parentage has been confirmed and we know Rhaegar and Lyanna were married and loved each other, I think it's safe to say Ned only mended his relationship and kept quiet about the truth of the rebellion being started on a lie to protect Jon and honor his beloved sister. Or as soon as Brandon was arrested as the monarch didn't appear to be in the mood to legally return the abducted girl? Each email has a link to unsubscribe. That Lyanna was abducted and raped. Robert was crowned king after King Aerys II Targaryen, his first cousin once removed, was killed during Robert's Rebellion. Everyone was just watching. He then sent Robert back to the Stormlands and Eddard back to the North to do the same. Only when Jon felt personally threatened and the deaths of the prisoners clear was there a real cause for rebellion. When Jon Arryn refused, he raised his banners, as well as those of Eddard (now Lord of Winterfell) and Robert in Rebellion. Though he grew peeved when Tywin seemed to receive all the credit for his success, Aerys allowed the Lannister leader to continue his work uninterrupted (though on occasion he would drunkenly insult Tywin's wife, Joanna). Killing Rhaegar at the Battle of . Stack Overflow for Teams is moving to its own domain! In the years preceding the outbreak of war, the actions of King Aerys II Targaryen had become increasingly erratic, believed by some to be . Does subclassing int to forbid negative integers break Liskov Substitution Principle? An error of premise, a foundation of something that is not true, and a large chain of events that fall off of it is sufficient for this term to be used and understood. Bran noted how this all meant that Robert's Rebellion, the civil war that set up the events of Game of Thrones, was based on a lie. Game of Thrones "Robert's Rebellion" Fancast - Comic Book Movie I recently got in a discussion on this sub over whether Robert's Rebellion was based on a lie or not and I hear that all the time so I wanted to make a post arguing why it was absolutely not based on a lie. Years before the series began, Robert was the Lord of the Storm's End and betrothed to Lyanna Stark, the only daughter of Lord Rickard Stark. Robert's Rebellion | Game of Thrones Wiki | Fandom The speculation was that Rhaegar would rally the lords against the mad king in the tourney of Harrenhall. Every Crown Begins With a Tinfoil Hat. Robert Baratheon's Rebellion all the lies folding right above the great war.A short video that describes the Robert's Rebellion that was based on a lie. The things we know or suspect. If so, anything between 36 hours and 10 minutes. The Starks could punish Lyanna (behind closed doors) for betraying her betrothal to Robert, but she didn't commit a, The most widely accepted definition of lying is the following: A lie is a statement made by one who does not believe it with the intention that someone else shall be led to believe it (Isenberg 1973, 248), Mobile app infrastructure being decommissioned, Favorite Question and Answers from Third Quarter 2022. How long do you think it took for them to travel? As you can see, if Robert's Rebellion was indeed built on rescuing Lyanna, why didn't it break out as soon as Lyanna was abducted? Though the Targaryen confidently waded into war, Robert Baratheon dealt a killing blow to Rhaegar with a quick swing of his warhammer. However, his defeat at Randyll Tarly's hands led to him escaping to avoid capture. Robert would still be unhappy, but you wouldn't have a good reason to start a revolution "because she loved him more than me". From Bran's point of view, Robert's rebellion was built on the lie that Brandon was told about Rhaegar "kidnapping and raping" Lyanna. Considering he already had produced multiple children with her, however, annulment apparently has a different meaning in Westeros than our own world. Yeah fuck that, NSFW Thread, lets for Daenerys has a favorite and its not Drogon. Site design / logo 2022 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Robert Baratheon's Rebellion all the lies folding right above the great Robert is a salty, sulking bitch baby. From Bran's point of view, Robert's rebellion was built on the lie that Brandon was told about Rhaegar "kidnapping and raping" Lyanna. MIT, Apache, GNU, etc.) Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Tensions were already high as Aerys committed violent acts against his own people and became increasingly paranoid, but the real motivation behind Robert's Rebellion was, typically, romantic in nature. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. (Robert, Ned, Jon Arryn etc and Jon Arryn raised the banners and marched against Aerys since he had no other option?). According to the World of Ice and Fire, when Rhaegar died Viserys became the NEW heir and baby Aegon was completely removed from the line of succession. The call of his heart drove him to pursue an extramarital relationship that would bore a hole in the peace of Westeros. Still, the realm did nothing in the months of prelude before the war broke out. Killing Rhaegar at the Battle of the Trident, his climactic duel turned the tides of the war in his favor. First, she is too much in love with him and we can see that he affects her greatly. Lyanna eloped with Rhaegar willingly, no crime was committed. Robert could've wanted to rebel the entire time, but was held back by Jon. Months presumably? With the help of Tywin Lannister as his Hand of the King, he did a remarkable job of keeping the Seven Kingdoms safe and prosperous. As Ned Stark remembers in A Song of Ice and Fire, this was the moment when all the smiles died" amid the concerned crowd. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. In conclusion, therefore the "lie" the rebellion is based on is that Rhaegar kidnapped and raped Lyanna. As Brandon was tied to a medieval hanging device, the Mad King placed a sword not far from his captive and offered an ultimatum: free yourself from the noose, and you may save your father. Expanding on Edlothiad's answer, The War never was about Lyanna's abduction! Bran Stark and Sam Tarly pieced together the puzzle of Jon Snow's parentage, his legitimacy and his claim to the Iron Throne tonight, in a flashback that confirmed Jon is not a bastard and this his real name is Aegon Targaryen. None of this was lost on Robert Baratheon, who was set to make Lyanna his bride. Warning: The following contains spoilers for Game of Thrones season 7. The captives and their fathers, all of them? Are certain conferences or fields "allocated" to certain universities? Where did the Tyrells' loyalty lie during Robert's Rebellion? "Lie" here means "misunderstanding". So did Bran Stark actually go to demand Lyanna from Aerys and Rhaegar's punishment? There, Ned encountered the remaining men of the Kingsguard and their terrifying leader, Ser Arthur Dayne, the best swordsman in all of the Seven Kingdoms. 2. Like with Helen of Troy, however, that elopement launched a thousand battles and forever altered the landscape of the Seven Kingdoms. It was based on a truth, the sole truth which is the survival instinct of every living thing. game of thrones male oc baratheon fanfiction I was just about to ask a follow up why they assumed that she was kidnapped and why no-one explained the misunderstanding to them, but your answer touches on that as well. Fast forward to Robert's Rebellion and we get varying accounts of how and why Robert Baratheon became king of Westeros. Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile, *This post contains spoilers for Game of Thrones season 7 episode 7 - 'The Dragon and the Wolf'*. Do FTDI serial port chips use a soft UART, or a hardware UART? Nonetheless, for the final push of the war, Robert was unable to personally lead the armies and gave the command to Ned Stark. Can an adult sue someone who violated them as a child? Cavill is a good actor and can pull off Robert. Now, we're only left with one doubt: Will Daenerys accept a different heir to the iron throne? He loved Lyanna, he married her, and he gave her a son: Aegon Targaryen, or as we've called him all these years, Jon Snow. Following the war, Robert married Cersei Lannister to ensure political stability. Why Robert's Rebellion was 'built on a lie' in Game of Thrones This has not yet come to light fully in the books; but we've already learned from Marwyn that they was they had more than a hand in the Dance of the Dragons. While the fighting at King's Landing had ceased, Ned Stark, Howland Reed and his band of men went to the Tower of Joy in the Red Mountains of Dorne. Though Lord Rickard obliged, Aerys labeled him a seditious leader upon his arrival at King's Landing. Notes: Inspired by In The. Check in on the accepted answer being unpinned; do we want to leave it as is Did Robert Baratheon earn the crown by his exploits or was it his right by succession? Bitter irony. @Edlothiad, Very true. Robert Baratheon led the forces of the rebels and gave his name to the war on account of having the best blood claim to the Iron Throne. There are a lot of things we still don't know about what happened back then. King Robert I Baratheon was the seventeenth ruler of the Seven Kingdoms and the first king of the Baratheon dynasty. Nobody raised any banners for Lyanna, nobody called their sworn swords. Why Battlestar Galactica Never Had Any Aliens, Everything Worst Roommate Ever Leaves Out About K.C. 2022-03-29 It saw the ruling Targaryen dynasty displaced from power after 280 years by the Baratheon dynasty. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the GooglePrivacy policyandTerms of serviceapply. Please try again later{{ /verifyErrors }}, Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number, Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters, You must be over 18 years old to register. Though Dayne declared that Rhaegar had ordered him to defend Lyanna Stark at the Tower of Joy, Ned and Howland saw them as traitors and cut them down. The Starks believing in the abduction, demand justice in a way that reads as treason. Ned only came to know (If Lyanna told him all) only in the end of the war and others were never aware. Honestly does anyone pay attention. Does protein consumption need to be interspersed throughout the day to be useful for muscle building? As for film criticism, he recognizes that he is not the proverbial man in the arena" and sometimes regrets calling Blade Runner 2049 boring" (though he would never dare to make this admission in a public setting). I think you've over dramatised the events, but yes, it was the call for the ward's heads which led to the rebellion. Lyanna was never taken from her future husband. He was taken prisoner and charged with treason, at which point his father, Rickard Stark, was summoned to ransom him. Following is a complete breakdown of their operations during the war: Battle of Ashford Back at King's Landing, Aerys made a crucial error by allowing Tywin through the gates. A Forum of Ice and Fire A Song of Ice and Fire & Game of Thrones Robert's Rebellion was based on a lie. However we must note that we do not know how much time did pass between the execution of prisoners and Royal edict calling for deaths of Ned and Bobby B. The odd southern alliances of rickard stark are intriguing as well given how little did The Northmen show interest in South since the conquest. The Silence of the Lions of the Rock who proudly carved "Hear me Roar" on their gates and sigil was deafening. It would have been a lie if they knew that Lyanna and Rhaegar eloped together and still started the rebellion telling everyone that Rhaegar has kidnapped her. It was never about Lyanna even though Robert personally wanted Lyanna more than he wanted a crown. As far as Robert Baratheon and Ned Stark were concerned, this was full-blown military payback for the alleged abduction of Lyanna, the unjust murders of the Stark leaders, and the disgrace sitting on the Iron Throne. Robert I Baratheon - A Wiki of Ice and Fire The Targaryen prince was dead, and Robert won his vengeance over Lyanna's captor. First, because it was kindled by a love by someone who in the present day (for the short time we meet Robert) is utterly devoid of love. fall out of roller coaster; authoritative figures; nhl lineup quiz; ice cream float strain; riding trainer stormwind shadowlands Robert tells us he did it for love because Prince Rhaegar took away his fiance, Lyanna Stark. Yes, abduction of precious Lyanna caused everyone around her to throw a fit. @Flater I think you're being too pedantic in this case. It would be more correct to call it "built on a. Robert's Rebellion was based on only one thing, which was the lives and safety of the Young Lords Stark and Baratheon. Wouldn't it be more appropriate to say that his rebellion was built on a misunderstanding? Doran Martell was the King Be honest. Why do the "<" and ">" characters seem to corrupt Windows folders? Vad gr man med sticklingar? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. apply to docments without the need to be rewritten? It could be that they received the word from the same bird that brought the royal command for execution of the young Lords. On the contrary Aerys was thinking of disinheriting him and naming his second son Viserys his heir. Sam (via Gilly in an earlier episode) was able to complete the picture for Bran, who was aware that Jon was the son of Rhaegar Targaryen and Lyanna Stark from his Tower of Joy flashback, but not that High Septon Maynard had annulled Rhaeger's marriage to Elia Martell before remarrying the prince to Lyanna. Per my understanding it was not. If they were unhappy, they would just talk to Lyanna, and not charge the Red Keep and ask for Rhaegar's head. Although the rebellion only began with the call for the heads of the wards, there is no reason for us to think Robert didn't plea to be allowed to rise up against the king and claim back his betrothed, however after the death of Rickard, Brandon and their companions and the call for the death of the two wards was there real reason for a revolution. Or at least Weeks? Game of Thrones: When Will Season 8 Premiere? Did Robert Baratheon lie about Lyanna? - stallaenfraga.com Much later than Lyanna's supposed "kidnapping" as it wasn't until the Mad King came for Robert and Ned's heads without legal cause that they fought back. But now that we are apprised of what actually happened back in the day, it's obvious that Rhaegar hadn't abducted Lyanna but had annulled his first marriage to finally get hitched to his lady love. Brave Lord Robert did nothing till then, remarkable for someone whose words are "Ours is the Fury", no Fury was seen at all. Did you expect HOTD to be successful? Chapter 2: The North Summary: Jon and Daenerys journey to Winterfell to meet the Starks and Dany learns the meaning of family. If the series should cover some past events in season 8, this definitely is one of the things that should be addressed in detail. @Annatar, indeed, there are many reasons to suspect that tourney of Harrenhal was actually an informal Great Council called to depose King Aerys , financed by either Tywin Lannister or Rhaegar himself. Naming Lyanna Stark the Queen of Love and Beauty would spell death for Rhaegar, and war for the Seven Kingdoms. How is it possible that your thoughts about Robert's Rebellion, F&B, Targaryens, Daenerys, Ned and Robert's friendship are exactly the same as mine. Aerys's councilors urged him to pardon Brandon Stark, as Rhaegar had stolen his sister and was the heir of the Warden of the North. While things didn't work out in the older brother's favour, who was later imprisoned and, was charged with treason along with his father Rickard Stark. The only lie in the rebellion was Robert's belief about Lyanna's love for him. This point of view his held by most of Westeros as the reason for Robert's rebellion. Ironic that Rhaegar's son was named by Ned Stark to protect him, after the first person to raise the banners against the mad king. Ned failed to understand that Rhaegar's orders were benevolent. ), Finally, we should probably not ignore the slow, subtle but determined involvement of the Citadel and perhaps house Hightower. HBO viewers guide, appendices, Robert's Rebellion entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Rhaegar Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Baratheon of King's Landing - Robert Baratheon entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Aerys II Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Arryn - Jon Arryn entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Baratheon of Dragonstone - Davos Seaworth entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Elia Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Viserys Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Targaryen - Rhaella Targaryen entry, HBO viewers guide, season 2 guide to houses, House Baratheon of Dragonstone - Stannis Baratheon entry, Wars of the First Men and the Children of the Forest. While this happened, Aerys then had Brandon brought in from his jail cell and into the Red Keep where he saw his father getting roasted alive. Article continues below advertisement. This enraged the leaders at Winterfell and spurred Lyanna's brother, Brandon Stark, to ride to King's Landing and demand Rhaegar be held responsible for his wanton actions. It is possible that (off-camera) someone who knew better lied, or someone expressed certainty beyond grounds and convinced them that this occurred.
Roma Vs Betis Prediction Forebet, Dysthymia Icd-10 Criteria, Virginia State Fair Concerts - 2022, Aws Quicksight Compliance, Barber Vintage Motorsports Museum Tickets, Water Softener For Espresso Machine, Parking Permit Rotterdam, Hemp Radiators Recipe,